Proctor Silex makes straightforward appliances that do their job without fuss. The 22305 toaster’s main advantage is its extra-wide slots. They easily accommodate thick-cut artisanal bread, bagels, and even frozen waffles without forcing a jam or requiring a pre-slice.

At 700 watts, it toasts quickly and evenly. The shade selector gives you reliable control, from a light warm-up to a deep crunch. The Toast Boost lever lifts smaller items like English muffins high enough for easy retrieval. Cool-touch exterior plastic keeps things safe on a crowded counter, and the auto shut-off is a fundamental safety feature you shouldn’t go without.

This is a plastic-bodied toaster, so it feels lightweight. It won’t have the premium heft of a stainless steel model. For the price, it delivers consistent performance for the most common breakfast tasks with minimal complication.