Hamilton Beach has been making reliable countertop appliances for over a century. The 25360 indoor grill stands out because its 450°F searing temperature and PFAS-free nonstick grate address two modern kitchen priorities: real grill marks and cleaner materials.

You get legitimate searing power from a 1200-watt element. The adjustable dial lets you manage everything from slow-cooking chicken to putting a char on vegetables. The 118-square-inch surface is the practical sweet spot—it fits about six burgers without crowding. A large, slide-out drip tray handles the grease, which is a major upgrade over models with tiny, awkward catch pans.

The removable nonstick plate is dishwasher-safe, turning the worst part of grilling into a simple cleanup. It’s a straightforward, durable tool that makes weeknight dinners significantly better. Just note that like all electric grills, it won’t replicate the smokiness of outdoor charcoal.